Friday, September 24, 2021

Biden, Hitler and Mussolini walk into a bar . . . .

Biden, Hitler and Mussolini walk into a bar. 

Biden, explaining to Hitler and Mussolini the reasons for what he believes are constitutional vaccine mandate laws, says: "This is not about freedom or personal choice. It’s about protecting yourself and those around you . . . ." In other words, safety.

Then Hitler reads the Presidential decree of 1933 which gave him extraordinary powers to take over state governments based on the idea of keeping Germany safe from communism, saying: "Thus, restrictions on personal liberty, on the right of free expression of opinion, including freedom of the press, on the right of assembly and the right of association, and violations of the privacy of postal, telegraphic, and telephonic communications, and warrants for house-searchers, orders for confiscations as well as restrictions on property, are also permissible beyond the legal limits otherwise prescribed."

Mussolini, explaining fascism, says: "The maxim that society exists only for the well-being and freedom of the individuals composing it does not seem to be in conformity with nature's plans, which care only for the species and seem ready to sacrifice the individual." In other words don't worry about individual rights, but only the group, in the name of safety.

Not a funny joke? I know. The quotes are real, but it's no joke at all. However, there is an important point. I am not saying Biden is just like Hitler or Mussolini. Yet, anyway. Though his intent to flood the country with immigrants based on his race theories (he has said it will be good when there isn't a "white" majority), his gross incompetence and the ongoing going leftist urging of more racism and their surge to power have made him one of the worst presidents in history in just a few months and is helping pave the road to fascism. It started before him and will likely continue long after.

It is so critical to recognize that fascism happens differently every time (that I will put it in my brand new font - Fjalla One, if you care). It just ends up the same, with authoritarianism and brutality. Hitler didn't show up suddenly in Germany in 1933 and say, come on everyone, lets get ready to murder.  It often starts slowly by a small group of very energetic people with a vendetta who prepare the conditions for it - feelings of great division in a society, the inability of the normal processes to handle change, the destruction or control of important government or public functions (e.g., the police, the media), feelings of victimization, hatred and lies, lies, lies. Often, like Hitler, they want the appearance of legality. 

And what's their solution in most events - more governmental power - allegedly for everyone's benefit, but really favoring one or more favored groups - and the consequential loss of individual rights. That German decree referred to above, was specifically promulgated based on the lie that it was necessary because (the Nazis claimed) the Reichstag fire was caused by Communists and Jews. How similar the January 6, insurrection is now claimed by Democrats and socialists to have been called for or incited by Trump (who literally did the opposite - asked for peaceful protest). If you listen to repeated Biden statements, the federal government will take away people's rights (by bullying those who choose not to get vaccinated) because of safety. We are racing down that road, and whatever means are necessary will be used, including the new "go to" reason to limit freedom - safety. 

Using safety to take away people's rights is not new. It's always been around. I'm certainly not anti-safety (or anti-vaccine, for that matter - I'm vaccinated and would have been first to get it if I could have been). When it doesn't violate constitutional rights, few things could be more important than safety for a myriad of reasons. But, as years go buy we see more and more of the use of safety to try and pass unconstitutional legislation or to legitimize a president to act without legislation. Whether its more cameras or tapping your phone or calling China to say don't worry - we won't let Trump nuke you, it is a very sellable way of ending freedom, overriding the laws or of dooming your society.

Concerning specifically these proposed federal mandates - I am not aware of any federal vaccine requirements before this (they will say it is not "required," but you will be fired or excluded if you don't go along and paid if you do). State and local vaccination laws, yes. Federal no. Even the Supreme Court case that upheld a smallpox vaccination mandate in 1905, Jacobsen v. Massachusetts, involved a state - not the federal government. If there is, I'll mea culpa. I'm always learning something new.

In fact, the Jacobsen case might be used to find the new federal mandates unconstitutional. It held, among other things: "The authority of the state to enact this statute is to be referred to what is commonly called the police power,- a power which the state did not surrender when becoming a member of the Union under the Constitution." The state, not the federal government, has the police powers. That's one of my chief complaints with Obamacare or even a Republican substitute - it used the opened up the entire health care system to federal intervention.

The federal government, despite every appearance of being able to legislate about any subject or issue it wishes, is actually supposed to be limited. Two cases not that long ago showed that congress couldn't just legislate about anything it desired. In 1995, in United States v. Lopez, it was held that "The Constitution...withhold[s] from Congress a plenary police power that would authorize enactment of every type of legislation." In fact, the court would not "pile inference upon inference" to convert the the Commerce Clause granting congress the right to legislate about interstate commerce to a general police power - which was the province of the states. Lopez concerned a federal attempt to regulate guns - it was about safety, of course. 

Five years after Lopez the court shot down another federal law, this time concerning violence to women. The law was clearly about safety. What rational person is not for protecting women or everyone, for that matter, from violence or is against gun safety (no, gun owners are not against gun safety)? People will always disagree about the best way to effectuate it, but the reason these were cases, was because of federal attempts at usurping state power. It probably has worked more than it has failed, mostly because the left keeps trying. 

Of course, Biden knows all about federalism and so do all the states. What Republicans and conservatives don't seem to get is that they just don't care. Do you remember not so long ago when Trump was president that some of the states with Democrat governments said if he tried to interfere with their handling of Covid-19 they would not listen to him, because it wasn't the federal government's place? What's the difference now? Just that a Democrat is in power in the White House. Here, for example, is an article from March, 2020 - in other words, the beginning of lockdowns and so forth, published in the Brookings Institute (probably the most famous left-wing think tank in the country) explaining to President Trump if he didn't want to violate the Constitution -Trump or governors: Who’s the boss? (brookings.edu). I will give them credit if they write a similar article now. 

Because Trump, unlike Biden, was not heading down the pathway of fascism, despite the left-wing drumbeat that he was fascism incarnate, he actually did not interfere with the states' Covid responses - and some, like New York and Michigan probably killed (I presume unintentionally) a lot of people in their control as a result. Will there ever be a real investigation into that? In any event, despite how vigilantly the governors protected their states while Trump was in office, I don't hear Democrat states complaining about the vaccine mandates and federalism now - only red states. 

Though federal powers have been greatly expanded since the 1905 Jacobsen case, which case I believe both sides will rely on), so too have the definitions of due process, privacy and equal protection - all expanded. In fact, both as a constitutional principle and as a subject of federal legislation, medical privacy has also grown tremendously (the HIPAA laws) as the notion of "my body, my choice." This will weigh against, not for, federal vaccine mandates. Not that the left is paying that any attention. 

Unfortunately I can no longer maintain the belief that our Supreme Court really binds itself by established law. Many of the justices prefer to establish law. That has been true of the right and left at times, but now seems like it is the goal of the left. If you don't believe it, ask yourself why if they can't get the justices to do it, they say - pack the court. Despite even the recriminations of Justice Thomas that it is not so, the Roberts Court seems to more about protecting the court as an institution and being liked by the media more so than actually applying the law. I suppose with the Democrats threats of court packing and Senator Goebbels' - sorry - Schumer's, public personal threats against individual judges if they did not vote the way his party wanted (I have never seen such a gleeful Nazi imitation by a U.S. Senator - Unhinged: Chuck Schumer Threatens Supreme Court Justices Gorsuch And Kavanaugh - YouTube), they are all rightly a little nervous of the court being diminished, even neutered, by the oncoming fascism (though I'm sure they would not put it that way). If people like Justice Thomas, who doesn't worry about what people think doesn't say so, who will? I didn't always think that way, but I've given up defending them, particularly Roberts. Not that I think he's a fascist, just deliberately determined to protect the court from the only ones attacking it - the left, by compromising as much as he can. He's not alone.

Why should I say that this mandate is on the road to fascism and not just that there is a new administrative rule I don't like? You have to look at the context and what is going on in our society. I could go on and on for another long-winded post (I excel at long-winded), but I won't. I write about it all the time and you can just look at past posts or the ones surely coming. You know - End border enforcement, abolish the electoral college, add D.C. or split states, pack the Supreme Court, threaten Supreme Court Justices, physically threaten Republican members of congress, all towards one party power; threaten our allies (not Trump, but Democratic congresspersons threatened Ukraine, institute modern racism (whites are inherently evil) through the schools, military, federal agencies, engage in censorship by partnership with tech companies that are largely the village square now, the established Clinton campaign and FBI attempts to derail Trump's campaign, attempts to derail his administration and impeach him with the silliest impeachments to date (they now mean nothing - just a conventional tool) and the like. 

We are in danger, not just a little bit, because of what's going on, but gravely so. And, people, many of whom would know better if not conditioned to almost a Pavlovian response into believing Trump was some kind of bogeyman controlling marauders like Barnaby in Babes in Toyland and about to nuke China. I can no longer be shocked that the decent, intelligent people I know believe this to the degree that almost nothing else matters and no set of facts can change it. I've read about it all my life, and have seen it too many times in the last few years.

I don't particularly like writing about this "stuff." Fascism, the iniquities of an administration, the divisions in society, etc. But, it's important and I have to continue. And if the Republicans ever claw back power and head towards fascism, I will continue the same. 

Tuesday, September 07, 2021

Does Black Lives Matter really hate black people?

Do you really belief any of what has been going on this past year has been good for black people? I can't see how. It is so destructive, I feel like they have lost a generation. Not that I believe most black people are for CRT or rioting or defunding the police (I think a great deal of them are white kids actually - and I have to add - some very ignorant white kids), but, it has to have a terrible impact on them. 

Looking back at my youth a few years ago, I believe after Muhammad Ali died, I realized that most of my childhood heroes were black. Most of them were athletes too, because most of my heroes were athletes period (pretty common for kids, I think). Not all of them were black, of course, but probably the majority. And some were not athletes, like Martin Luther King, Jr. The thing was, I didn't care what color they were. I was born in 1959. The '60s, of course, was a famously racist time. MLK, Jr. was assassinated, Malcolm X was a pariah (I've come to appreciate him more now). Muhammad Ali was a hero to many, but was a goat to others for converting to Islam, changing his name and refusing the draft. 

For a long time, the history of civil rights was a special interest for me - decades of reading. But, what I learned was for educational purposes and didn't really didn't make me any more aware of what was known to all reasonably intelligent people with even a smattering of education - that for centuries blacks were oppressed - even murderously oppressed. 

The '70s showed progress, but there was still a lot of racism. In the '70s the case of Loving v. Virginia was won by a wed couple in the Supreme Court, striking down a Virginia law that did not allow those of different races to marry. It is still stunning to me, and I'm sure to others, that this was actually a law in our country 50 years ago that needed to be struck down.

In the '80s, '90s, '00s and twenty-teens, racism declined further. Since roughly the 1950s, civil rights laws were enacted, and most famously and effectively in the '60s.  You can argue about the unconstitutionality of some them. You can argue about the wisdom of some of them, or fairness. But, you can't reasonably argue but that the laws of this country have since favored minorities and do not oppress them. 

Remarkably, but also predictably, this country elected, Barack Obama, a black man as president in 2008. You can argue he's bi-racial, not black - his mother and her parents were white - but he "identified" black and almost everyone describes him as black. Not only was he black, but he was clearly on the side of blacks as opposed to whites. In every black v. white issue, many of them concocted, he seemed to reflexively leap to the side of the blacks, rather than seek out facts and justice (by justice, I mean actual justice, not what is called "social justice," which is another form of racism). 

When a brouhaha broke out about a black Harvard professor who was stopped by the local police from breaking into his own home (the door was jammed, and a neighbor called the police), Obama immediately said the police "acted stupidly." He later relented and helped make peace. 

When George Zimmerman shot Trayvon Martin in Florida, he said that "Trayvon" could have been his son. Not, George, whose head was being beaten into the ground when he shot the teenage boy, saving his own life. As I've said many times here, I watched the trial. Even the prosecution witnesses couldn't help but testify in a way that showed it was self-defense. Because it was clearly self-defense. That didn't stop Obama from making his statement. 

When Ferguson, Missouri blew up over Michael Brown's shooting, and the grand jury would not indict (always uncommon), he made a speech absolutely decrying violence, but at the same time making it clear that there would be a federal investigation into many communities and said not a single word about Darren Wilson, the officer who was treated like a murderer, despite the fact that many witnesses, including blacks, corroborated his story, and a number of the witnesses against Wilson actually admitted they made their stories up - or they were just not possible. The federal investigation also found that Officer Wilson, who had to quit his job and now lives in hiding, acted in self-defense. On its face, his speech may seem balanced to you. But, it is difficult to call it that when what happened was rather one sided, and favored the officer.

Obama was undoubtedly protected, and while it may be partly because he is a Democrat, and has the media in his pocket (despite the fact that many complained how opaque and threatening to journalists his administration was), part of it has to do with his skin color, for which he was favored, not oppressed. After all, this is the president who won a Nobel Prize for being elected, and he himself seemed embarrassed because he hadn't done anything yet. In fact, it is almost never mentioned that right after the Putin and Obama personally met in America in 2015, Russia unannounced, but long planned, secured its airbase on the Mediterranean in Syria. Can I prove that Obama gave it his okay? No. I don't know if Putin just told him what he was doing de facto or sounded him out, but it was not opposed. But the meeting was at Putin's request and I can't imagine that Obama would have been furious had he not known. That airbase is now permanent.

He was able to get away with telling Russia's prime minister that he would be more flexible after the election - in other words, essentially saying to America's enemy, Don't worry, I'll lie to the American people to get elected again - and we only know it because it was caught on a live mike (though some people tell me they never heard of such a thing happening, given the press's non). U don't think it was treasonous, but I do think impeachable.

Obama was also able to get away with an extended period of time in excess of that allotted by the War Powers Act helping Europe bomb away in Libya, getting rid of a bad guy, Ghaddafi, but also sending that country into a chaotic tailspin that has lasted to this day. He was able to survive the blowback from the tragedy that unfolded in Benghazi, Libya, when a terrorist group killed our ambassador and others due to a lack of American security. Compare, all this happened and no impeachment, but Donald Trump was impeached because he asked a president of another country for a favor and because some of his supporters attacked the capitol house (after Trump told them to protest "peacefully").  In fact, as to everything Obama did, you can only ask, can you imagine if Trump did that?

Of course, Obama, who was very sensitive about minority issues, knew very well that things had gotten tremendously better in America for them, and though prejudice exists, it was better than ever. We know this because, three years after BLM started its assaults on capitalism (yes, sorry), on race relations, on justice, he kept saying so. I never get tired of quoting this because it puts the lie to the false narrative of the left that we have a systemically racist country:

"I am not saying gaps do not persist. Obviously, they do. Racism persists. Inequality persists. Don’t worry -- I’m going to get to that. But I wanted to start, Class of 2016, by opening your eyes to the moment that you are in. If you had to choose one moment in history in which you could be born, and you didn’t know ahead of time who you were going to be -- what nationality, what gender, what race, whether you’d be rich or poor, gay or straight, what faith you'd be born into -- you wouldn’t choose 100 years ago. You wouldn’t choose the fifties, or the sixties, or the seventies. You’d choose right now. If you had to choose a time to be, in the words of Lorraine Hansberry, “young, gifted, and black” in America, you would choose right now."

If you read the whole speech, you will see that most of minority's experiences were  better, much better, than it had been. And getting better still. Obama's full remarks at Howard University commencement ceremony - POLITICOPOLITICOSearchSearchCloseBack ButtonSearch IconFilter Icon.

So, if that was the case in 2016, why are we having the discussion now that things aren't better, that blacks wouldn't want to be born here and now?  Why isn't Obama still saying it. Well, that's simple. Because the radicals won. And when I say radicals, it is not a synonym for blacks. There are blacks, Hispanics and whites, lots of whites, and others, proselytizing away with radical cunning. While we were busy working, living and playing, they won the schools, the media, big tech, and many branches of government who now believe that Barack Obama was wrong (not that they know he said it), and that we are systemically racist. 

Was he wrong? 

Maybe, coached by co-workers or at school, repeatedly told it by CNN or one of the other radical outlets, that seem all for socialism while racking up millions in capitalist activities, you believe he was wrong then too. 

So, I ask you, do you really think this is good for black people? I mean, Black Lives Matter name implies it should care for black people, doesn't it? Then why have they asked to defund the police, leading to THOUSANDS of deaths and shootings (we usually count deaths, but being shot can destroy a life too) that sprung immediately upon the cries for no more police. In Portland, it is so bad - that is, the idiot government and prosecutors are so harsh on the police, that they now just let Antifa fight it out with the Proud Boys or whomever else. That's Oregon now and much of America thinks it wants to head that way too. Is that what you think is good for black people, watching their neighborhoods burn, watching their kids die, watching looting and so many crimes go unpunished. 

Well, thank goodness, many actual black people don't think so. Not that long after Floyd's death and the rioting and defund movement started, a poll showed that over 80% of blacks - so by far most - wanted the same or more police? Why wouldn't they? The best friends blacks in poor urban neighborhoods have are police. In Chicago where police have been neutered - they can't even chase a suspect without permission from a supervisor - homicides and shootings continue to spiral out of control. 58 people got shot, including children, last weekend there, with five dying. It was the most shootings this year, but not by far the most deaths. 12 died one weekend this year. These are predominantly black neighborhoods. Who are they helping by muzzling the police? Not black people. Not poor black people. 

Does BLM care? Do you care? 

What's happening in Chicago is happening to a large extent in cities, particularly Democrat led cities throughout the country. I've said this before but let me say it again - BLM's defund the police movement has led to the killings of blacks in a short time at a much faster rate than the KKK and others ever lynched them over their whole history. Maybe you think it is impossible, but it's crystal clear. According to the NAACP, obviously a pro-black organization (that used to believe in civil rights but now just hurts blacks), they have concluded that between 1882 and 1968 3,446 blacks were lynched. Look at the numbers of blacks who have died as a result of under-policing. We can't give an exact number but according to Time (a left leaning magazine) "according to Everytown for Gun Safety, a non-profit organization that advocates for stricter gun laws, Black Americans make up 68% of homicide victims in larger cities, many of them victims of gun violence." Remember, they are only about 12% of the population, so do the math. By the way, whites generally aren't killing them. It is in fact relatively rare, as it is for a cop to kill an unarmed black person. So, probably in 6 months of post Floyd hysteria and additional 2500 blacks, including little children died from homicide. We are on another record pace this year. And until cops are empowered again - and that means allowed to defend themselves, reasonably protected by the law and permitted to be aggressive with the bad guys, it is going to keep getting worse. Much worse.

In America, homicides went up from about 16,000 to about 20,000 - a rise of 4,000 people. It is reasonable, based on what we know to therefore estimate that perhaps somewhere between 2000-2500 more blacks died IN SIX MONTHS at least indirectly as a result of the under-policing caused by the defund and defang the police movements. 

Maybe you don't care, because you really don't care about black people. But, I think it is because it hasn't hit you personally yet.

Oregon may lead the country in wokepidity (if you can't guess - short for woke stupidity). There, the bar association has announced they will no longer be interested in merit, but diversity. In other words, they don't care if a black lawyer is qualified, if he/she hurts the clients, or if people don't respect black lawyers. But, they are not alone. Our vaunted AMA, whose intelligence I have to question, has pretty much said the same about doctors going forward. But, Oregon still wants to lead the parade and has announced that blacks no longer need worry about learning to read, write or do arithmetic to get out of high school. Talk about the soft racism of low expectations. What are they doing to these kids? Don't they care?

Do you? 

Now the debate by the language police is that "black" (no longer wrong to say, apparently) should be spelled with a capital "B" but white with a small "w" (but you tell me that we don't have a fascist society?), because . . . why? Do you think if we spell black "Black" and white just the way it is that blacks/Blacks will feel better about themselves, as if they are dumb animals that will be filled with pride if you let them eat first (it worked with my cats)? Why do you think they need to feel better? Who says they feel inferior? Well, not a trick question, but it is a basic premise of what is (I say laughingly) called Critical Race Theory, a form of racism (or fascism, which is authoritarianism based on racism). It's racism dressed up to look like it belongs in academia. CRT actually teaches white kids (and adults) to feel as they are a threat to western society and every black person. It also teaches, for example, blacks to feel inferior. Apparently, when Verizon succumbed to what is becoming a moral plague, teaching white employees they are a danger to society, it's efforts to browbeat them included this message by a black man in a video: "As a black man in [America], we are viewed as less than. We are viewed as inferior. We are viewed that our life is not as valuable as anyone else.” It's actually worse than that, they lecture that whatever whites might fear, they can't compare to the fears and anxiety's of blacks. Why? Because they clearly think blacks are inferior and live in fear. Not me saying this. They are. 

Do you agree that we should teach black kids that they will live in fear? I know many blacks don't agree. In fact, some blacks all over the country are fighting back against a lot of this nonsense. I loved this statement by Coleman Hughes, a writer who two years ago in a congressional hearing on reparations:

"Reparations by definition are only given to victims, so the moment you give me reparations, you’ve made me into a victim without my consent. Not just that, you’ve made 1/3 of black Americans who poll against reparations into victims without their consent, and black Americans have fought too long for the right to define themselves to be spoken for in such a condescending manner."

Hughes is a talented guy. He was going to Juilliard to play the trombone, dropped out to become a hip/hop performer and then went and got his B.A. in philosophy from Colombia U. But, there I go, treating him like an individual rather than just by the color of his skin. What was I thinking?

As with all my posts, I could go on and on. But, you likely have a football game or Netflix presentation to watch, and I know I get about 3-5 minutes of your time.

So, let me end with this little personal comment. I don't watch tv anymore unless I'm in a room with someone who has it on. This past New Years' I agreed with my friends to come over for the evening and watch the programs with the ball dropping on Times Square and the like. And, it was okay. But, then, just after midnight, the channel we were watching put on an ad for BLM, because, I guess, they wanted us to end the year with bad feelings, disharmony and lies. At the end, they showed a march and they focused in on the little girl (I don't remember how old, but young) marching along with everyone and fixing the  camera with a fierce glare. In reality, I don't know if she was glaring at her mother who was making her march or if she was looking at someone eating her dessert. But, what the narrative they were presenting was that she was trying to say - I'm not going to put up with your oppression and I'm going to be fearless and fight you. 

It made me really sad. Because if she really was fixing us with the fierce glare of resistance, how sad for her. How sad the loss of her childhood. How sad for a generation of both black and white kids who are learning from the media and even trusted teachers that success does not come from hard work and studying, but from angering or frightening people, burning (especially cops, if they can), looting and rioting. That Martin Luther King, Jr. (if they've even heard of him) was wrong about judging people by the content of their character rather than the color of the skin - but that the reverse is true. They are learning that they are not individuals, but cogs in a color scheme, that there is not justice for people, but only groups (if it sounds a little Marxist, remember, BLM is openly Marxist). That their country, who must have been confused when it elected a black man twice, doesn't love them, but hates them - and they should hate it and its history. That sticks and stones break your bones and names are worse. They are learning not brotherhood, but enmity, no unity but division, not pride, but to seek victimhood. 

And they are learning all these things from the very institutions that one would hope would be succoring them, not suckering them. 

Of course, it's not everyone, and it's our job to open our mouths and make sure kids and grandkids learn the truth. Don't give up on them. 


Tuesday, August 17, 2021

Baghdad Biden?

 A few weeks ago I ended my post on Simone Biles with:

"Wait a second . . I just had a great idea - 

Why can't she just blame Trump?"

It wasn't really a joke. The "But Trump" defense has been reigning supreme since Biden took office just as during Trump's terms his followers were trained to holler "Obama did it" for every Trump triumph. However much more Biden divides this country, however much more he weakens it, he is just going to blame Trump while people like Nancy Pelosi and Don Lemon and all the pod people who seemed to be able to hypnotize perfectly normal, even intelligent Americans, will cheer JB or razz DT. Good job Joe. Ohhhh, that Trump (fist shake). As we have seen, it works when you have almost the entire media behind you. However, it is gotten so bad, that even a CNN and the like who are perfectly comfortable not reporting Antifa outrages or anything that can hurt the "narrative" have at least to some degree reported the news from Afghanistan. What size disaster will it take before they realize what they have created by electing him?

Some Democrat's have admitted what a disaster this is. Leon Panetta, Obama's CIA director has said: "President Kennedy took responsibility for what took place. I strongly recommend to President Biden that he take responsibility ... admit the mistakes that were made." 

Democrat rep. Jason Crow (former Army Ranger) stated: "I’m not going to mince my words on this: We didn’t need to be in this position. We didn’t need to be seeing the scenes we’re seeing at Kabul’s airport with our Afghan friends climbing aboard C-17s. We should have started this evacuation months ago. Had we done that, tens of thousands of folks could have been brought to safety. It could have been done deliberately and methodically. That was a missed opportunity.”

Massacussett's Democrat and former Marine Seth Moulton said: "We need a plan. We need someone in charge. Honestly, we still haven’t really seen the plan. They had weeks of opportunity. They had an amazing coalition of liberal and conservative lawmakers who were willing to support the administration in this effort. In my mind this was not just a national security mistake, but a political mistake, too.”

A few other Democrats have spoken out, but not enough. And certainly not the commander-in-chief.

After one of the most humiliating military boondoggles of our history, up their with our flight from Saigon, Jimmy Carter's disastrous Operation Eagle Claw to rescue the hostages and  Black Hawk Down in Somalia, Biden, who should be forever known as Baghdad Biden for his lack of any credibility in spinning the disaster, is trying to blame Trump . . . even though Biden took office almost 7 months ago. He had enough time to make the military woke, but not enough time to plan this?

Biden said in his August 16th press conference - where, once again, he took no questions, while the disaster is still unfolding "I am the President of the United States of America and the buck stops with me," but he absolutely meant "The Buck stops with Trump," as immediately he blamed it on a deal he claims to be stuck with struck by Trump with the Taliban.

Their option, he said, was to recommit to fighting the Taliban in the "Spring fighting season," which I guess they did not want to do (uhhh . . . is it Spring?). Okay, but, doesn't that mean. . . . he agrees with what Trump did? Sure, on the one hand, but it sure doesn't seem like it. Only the day before that he stated that Trump left the Taliban in the strongest position since 2001. Actually, leaving Afghanistan was not only Trump's plan - but Obama's plan - one of the few things they agreed on. This from NPR, hardly Trump territory, in July, 2016:

"Obama's drawdown in Afghanistan initially proceeded as planned during his second term, and he announced an end to U.S. combat operations at the end of 2014.

The president said then about 10,000 troops would remain to train the Afghans, though they too would leave that country by the time Obama left the White House.

Obama projected that U.S. troops would only have a "normal embassy presence" in Kabul by the end of 2016. U.S. Marines guard American embassies around the world."

Biden is basically saying that he's stuck with Trump's peace agreement because there are no good options, and the immediate folding of Afghan's government proves it is time to leave, because they have no fight in them, despite overwhelming manpower and material advantages. 

Okay, that's been the presidential position for at least 13 years . . . except, the new president, the one in office, gets to do it in the way he wants, not the way the last one wanted. I mean, really, he came into office and immediately began hammering out presidential order after order, shredding everything that Trump did as fast as he could (a few federal district courts now stopping some of it). He could have done this as fast or slow as necessary to protect people and to stop the Taliban from being armed by us. 

And guess what? When Trump lowered the American troop level to 2500, the Taliban did not take over the country or Kabul, though it was known it was still a threat. Biden threatening to wreak hell on them if they did this obviously had the same nil effect it seems to be having on our other enemies.

"We planned for every contingency, but, the truth is, this did unfold more quickly than we anticipated." Okay, but that means, you got it wrong. Not just a little wrong. Incredibly wrong. And, frankly, you couldn't have planned for every contingency.  If you planned for every contingency, there wouldn't be reports of gunfire and deaths already, you wouldn't be saying your hearts go out to the Afghanies who helped us - they'd be safe.

How much has this epic failure hurt us? I remember Democrats actually saying that Trump endangered our national security with a single question in front of many witnesses on the telephone - by asking Ukraine's president to check up on corruption (which definitely was aimed at helping Trump with his likely opponent, Biden). Leave aside that even anti-Trump witnesses at the impeachment hearings had to admit (all of them) that Trump did more for Ukraine than Obama and that nothing was actually done to Ukraine - do you think these same Democrats will find that that this great display of Biden's incompetency in military matters has hurt our national security? 

If you believe it will, you do not know most of those elected to government. They will just blame Trump for anything too big to spin as victory, like they do with Biden's disaster at the border. Even CNN can't pretend the Taliban waltzing back into power immediately is a victory. Our Pentagon already had to admit that the outlook on probable increased terrorism suddenly changed and we will have to see how. Hmmm. Who's going to do that? This same administration which couldn't predict what has been obvious for a long time - when we leave in the way we did, without taking care of our Afghan allies, our own civilians and our equipment, the Taliban will fill the vacuum and fast.  

Americans are in danger of their freedom and lives, in danger of being tortured or taken hostage - are being told to shelter in place and not to contact the embassy. They do get to fill out forms though! And the Afghanies? Those poor women (half the country) who will lose all freedom, having tasted it, will become slaves again or perhaps young ones will become so for the first time -- what has Biden done to them? 

Whenever I discuss Afghanistan I admit that I have changed my mind back and forth about this mountainous land of the lost that has been a death trap for the British, the Russians and us.  Of the three, America, we did it the best, at least gave some people, especially the women a chance. Now, thanks to a president almost gloriously incompetent, we who maintained at least what we had safely with 2500 troops under Trump, idiotically abandoned this nation in a way that we are rushing back 3000, wait 5000, or is it now 6000 soldiers, with no time for a real plan. 

Obviously we don't want to lose American lives without a good reason that we collectively feel the sacrifice of heroes is necessary. Obviously we can't police the world. But, obviously, we don't want the bad guys in the world laughing at our military's incompetency or to waste the deaths of Americans or Afghanies in the fight for that country, though it was initially to destroy Al Qaeda. Putin and Xi are watching this and it keeps getting better and better for them. I tell you right now, I believe that soon after the 2022 Olympics in China, Xi will begin to up the pressure in a way Biden will not be able to fathom.

This president, who previously said, “The Taliban is not the North Vietnamese army. They’re not remotely comparable in terms of capability. There's going to be no circumstances where you’re going to see people being lifted off the roof of a US Embassy in Afghanistan,” was plain wrong as that is exactly what is happening. Video: US Embassy in Afghanistan is evacuated - CNN Video. Video shows Afghans clinging to outside of US military plane as it takes off in Kabul - CNN Video. Remember - this is CNN reporting this - imagine how bad it has to be for that to happen. Besides, what contingencies did this administration actually plan for - what to do if the Taliban all fled into Pakistan after we left? 

As our Goebbels like Majority Leader, Chuck Schumer, recently said about people who were going to manufacture or buy fake vaccine proof - "Who could be so stupid?" Well, Biden can. It makes you wonder - was he really just a gaffe machine, or is there an almost uncanny lack of the most basic common sense?

And are you, dear readers, or those of you who voted for Biden, really going to still say you are glad he won?

Even if you leave aside this debacle, we are talking about an administration that has seen the highest inflation in 13 years, the highest gas prices since the Obama administration and job openings hitting a record high while at the same time unemployment setting a 20 year high - obviously due to Biden insisting that people on unemployment still get paid more money for doing nothing than they would if they had a job even though we are no longer locking down and jobs are ample. This is the administration you voted for training our military and federal agencies in critical race theory - a racist theory that includes if you are white you are inherently racist. This is the same administration that has had to be stopped by federal courts from its racist debt forgiveness and grant programs based on skin color. It is the same administration that literally undid the fix Trump made at the border by creating a record setting disaster (which has gotten even worse since I posted on it on June 15th). It is so bad that it has resulted in courts ordering the federal government to revert to Trump's Stay in Mexico policy (Biden threw it out first thing in office).

The truth is, Russia did start rushing troops to the Ukraine border and China did start practicing its future raids on Taiwan right after Biden took office. The truth is that Biden and no one else created the border crisis which it appears he doesn't even care about stopping and has begun to severely damage our economy. 

The truth is that Trump pushed our fellow NATO members to pay their agreed dues, that he fulfilled our promise to Israel to make Jerusalem the home of our embassy, that he stopped payments to a Palestinian government that supports the families of terrorist bombers (we now pay for that in our aid that Biden restarted), that he did destroy ISIS, at least for the time when Obama watched it grow, that he did put Noko on its best behavior (even if still bad), that he did force China to the bargaining table (and if he had won, would have had even more success) and Putin got nowhere on Ukraine. The truth is that he did fix an out of control border, did shut down our border after COVID started while Biden and others called him a racist, that he did start Operation Warp Speed so that we could develop a vaccine as fast as possible and pre-world retraction because of COVID, took the government out of the way so that we have one of the best economies we've ever had. And he did this in the face of the most vicious and lying opposition since John Wilkes Booth leaped off the balcony.

Biden supporters (or Trump haters) - I know it is hard to admit that your political beliefs were wrong. I've had to come to that reckoning in my own life in my late 20s and it's not fun. I know for 5 years you've been watching hysterical anti-Trump messages in  the media and that you may be repeating the mantra's - Trump's too this or Trump's too that, without any meat. I know you watched the Democrat-led embarrassments of the Russia hoax, the two impeachments, the Kavanaugh hearing and now the hyperbolic claims treating January 6th as the day the only riot that ever happened in America occurred complete with the lies that Brian Sicknick was murdered and Ashlee Babbitt was not. And as the resurgence of Covid-19 in this country throws us more obstacles to success after this president, then a candidate, either brazenly lied or was incomparably stupid in saying that Trump caused 400,000 deaths.

I say to you, in the immortal words of Short Run in The Temple of Doom  - Wake up, Indie!!!!!!

Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom 4K - Wake up Dr. Jones. (bitchute.com)

I expect no miracles.

Tuesday, July 27, 2021

What does Simone Biles quitting mean about our country and the "woke" revolution. It means a lot.

I know, this is mean. I know, I couldn't get over a pommel horse with a trampoline to jump off of - so who am I to say anything? Well, I'll tell you, I'm not an Olympic champion. I'm not the greatest female gymnast in history - maybe just the best gymnast in history - or even one of the best athletes ever period. She is. And it means something that she quit today. I know we will hear about depression and all that stuff, maybe even Larry Nassar (I'd never make fun of anyone for being molested, but I've already seen reference to him today hinting he was to blame this - come on), but for an Olympic athlete . . . the greats overcome. What did Deflategate do to Tom Brady? Think that was easy for him? Well, he came back like a house on fire, didn't he? How much pressure was it when the Patriots were 25 points down in the Super Bowl? What did four years off from boxing do to Ali? Came back. Became champion again. That applies to all of athletes. The great champs come back and they don't quit. 

Aly Reisman said it was too much pressure on Simone. Well, how much pressure was there on Aly when she came back and her coaches wouldn't initially look at her right in front of them. Was it too much pressure for Dan Jansen who humiliated himself Olympic game after Olympic game to suck it up and win the Gold in his last race? Was it too much pressure when Dave Wottle was so far back in the 1972 men's 800 meters that even I thought he should just stop, but he went on to win with an amazing kick? Was it too much pressure when running a marathon Hayley Sutter collapsed before the finish line and crawled across to qualify?   

We could go on with these stories because the Olympics are full of them. These amazing athletes are all under tremendous pressure - it's always too much. Even their families are under tremendous pressure just watching. But, they persevere. In 2012 these words from Tennyson were put up in the Olympic Village for all to see - "‘To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield’ – was selected as the inscription for a wall in the athlete’s village at the 2012 London Olympic Games." 

Baron de Coubertin, who founded the modern games said - "The important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win, but to take part; the important thing in Life is not triumph, but the struggle; the essential thing is not to have conquered but to have fought well. To spread these principles is to build up a strong and more valiant and, above all, more scrupulous and more generous humanity."

That's not what Simone seem to believe when she sat down. Not in the individual competition. The team competition. I expect more to come. The U.S. team seems to be mentally beaten as a group, even though we will win many medals.  

Am I being too hard on this young woman? Horse feathers! She's operated under unbelievable pressure so many times - she's ten times tougher than me. That's not why I think she quit. I'm going to get to that. And I know some of you will think, now he's gone too far. Not everything is about our problems. Well, not everything is, but if you read the words I have been writing here, I am not unclear - we are a sick nation undergoing the institution of fascism. Fascism is viral and pretty much smears everything with its filth.

I know it seems unrelated, but as soon as I saw it I thought about Naomi Osaka, who I rooted for like crazy against Serena at the U.S. Open several years ago, quitting at the French Open and not attending Wimbledon, citing mental issues. I know, who am I? Maybe she does. I don't think so. I think she is an amazing athlete who has been taught when you are upset, even in sports, quit. And, now Simone quits too. Completely different circumstances? Nothing to do with each other? I don't know. I do notice that Naomi, who competed in the Olympics for Japan, just lost to someone way below her own talent level.

I have no proof of what I am about to say and feel free to consider me the worst person in the world if it hurts your feelings. This is what happens when you take a country and tell everyone that they are racists, that the way to succeed isn't through education and effort, you know, at first you don't succeed try, try again, but to riot and blame it on everything but what the problems really are. This is what happens when we tell people that it's okay to get people fired by saying "I don't feel safe," and get people fired. This is what happen when half of the country thinks it was okay for people to show up at Kavanaugh's hearing and shriek or others to pretend to be so upset that they claw at the doors of the Supreme Court (with a completely unmolested security guard standing nearby). This is what happens when people start believing what is important is an offended person's feelings and not the intent of the speaker. This is what happens when the youth in your nation are propagandized into believing that our country is systemically racist and look the other way or even cheer when they disparage their own country while competing on the team.

Yes, we've completely forgotten the idea of team. I'm not watching (I'm boycotting all tv anyway - but if I wanted to I'd watch). I still remember the one time this year I agreed to watch a few hours of tv on New Years Eve to be sociable with friends, and got treated to a BLM commercial complete with some poor little girl marching who glared at the tv as if to say - I'm oppressed but I hate you and will fight you. A little girl. Those bastards. They really don't care what happens to kids, including minority kids, if they can ride this hate to power. 

How do Olympians who are proud of their country, want to fight for glory and wave a flag, feel when they see others protesting it? I bet it intimidates them. People don't like being called racist and they don't like being politicized against their will. Who is going to grab the flag Ã  la George Foreman and wave it around (days after the Tommie Smith, John Carlos protest)? George is still proud of it and knows he is free. Great interview with him at George Foreman: ‘If I had to do it all over again, I would have had two flags’ (theundefeated.com). That's right - he said if he could do it again there would be two flags waving. Guess that go over well with our woke friends.

As usual, I want to make it as clear as possible what I am saying because someone can always misunderstand, misinterpret or twist it into something else. I don't know Simone Biles. Maybe she is patriotic. But she has signaled she is about the me-too movement (a great idea that almost immediately went off the rails and became about politics) and BLM. She had no problem with all those supposedly for George Floyd but somehow was terribly disturbed by the January 6th riot at the capital. Fine, what can we expect from her when even an all-time great on the brink of retirement like Drew Brees embarasses himself by walking back his support for his country. 

Wait a second . . I just had a great idea - 

Why can't she just blame Trump? I mean, the Biden administration blames him for everything that goes wrong. Am I being silly? I don't know. These stories usually have another shoe to drop. Sometimes excuses take a while to roll out. Let's see if this becomes about other things, Nassar, racism, Trump. I hope not, but its almost subliminally there. We spent four years with people saying they couldn't have relationships or babies or stay out of therapy because of Trump. Why not this? 

It would be really nice, an Olympic sized story, if Simone came back and kicked ass in the individual competition. Personally, I don't think after quitting on your team even the peerless Simone should get that chance. But, the coaches want to win (I think) and she is still absolutely the best chance. It would be nice if other athletes, instead of saying, well, if even best in the worldsies like Naomi and Simone can quit, how can I stand the pressure? This is, I'm afraid, the lesson to all the little kids out there. 

But, don't worry, Simone, Kerry Strug is pulling on her gym outfit one more time right now just in case the team needs her.


 





Monday, July 05, 2021

So, why is America's Perverted Dad out of jail - and should he be?

What, no fascism report today? Coming soon. But, today . . . someone most of us consider a rapist is now free (although he served a few years), and why we should be glad. 

Tough call, but ultimately, but I agree with the 7 members of Pennsylvania's high court who have not only tossed Cosby's conviction, but also made sure he will not be prosecuted again. Not that they were doing his bidding, and he has no rational reason to feel vindicated (he seems to think so), but they put law over public opinion, something I don't, for example, think that every judge does by a long stretch. E.g., the Judge in Chauvin gave him a sentence based on appeasing rioters, in my view, and not based on commonplace standards for a conviction for a non-intentional murder. 

Cosby seems very guilty to me, if not of this particular case (I do not think I could have voted for a verdict that he assaulted the victim against her will, beyond a reasonable doubt (see below, for why), even with the testimony of the five other women who claim he assaulted them. Naturally, he's not going to be tried in those other cases as the statutes of limitations have all expired, but, it is hard to believe that the 60 women who have no reason to step forward against a beloved non-political figure, especially, as he mentored and helped some and even more so, they are in many cases older, even grandparents and they can have no benefit from doing this. 

But, this decision was about law, not feelings or outrage and I am glad to see it whenever it happens, even if someone we think is guilty goes free. Right now our country is undergoing an upheaval by those who cry for "justice" without ever saying what it means, and pretending they are victims and others (including tiny children due to their skin color). I know that very few people will read the decision, which is really long and thorough (sometimes repetitive) and also am aware that the media, almost all of it, tends to treat these matters politically or for news shock, and not legally. Sometimes I watch entire trials (Chauvin, Zimmerman, Kennedy Smith (that was the Kennedy heir rape case in Florida, which I think it was the first one on Court TV). I did not follow the Cosby case closely and if it was on tv, I did not watch it. Here, I am completely following the court's rendition, which I have not heard criticized, at least. When I review these court cases, what I most want to do is try and cut out legal mumbo-jumbo and make it more understandable for non-professionals (almost most literate people, could read and understand the whole thing, if only they would). But, because this is about a sex or violence, however you like it, and, let's face it, people don't mind reading about this, I can give you some detail without scaring you away.

What and when happened?

Andrea Constand claimed that Cosby assaulted her in 2004. She did not make the complaint until a year later, during which time she remained a friend of his.  The County District Attorney was Bruce Castor. After investigation, he concluded that because she did not file her complaint for a long time and because there was no forensic evidence and he believed that in all likelihood the testimony of other potential victims would not be allowed, without a confession, "there was insufficient credible and admissible evidence upon which any charge against Mr. Cosby related to the Constand incident could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt."

They met in 2002 in connection with Temple University, where she had gotten a job. It's a school with which Cosby was well connected. She soon after came to his home and when he came into the room later  (I don't get this part - she ate dinner alone???), he sat next to her on the couch and put his hand on her thigh. "Constand was not bothered by Cosby's advance." The next time she ate dinner there (again, alone???), he came back in to have a conversation. He sat next to her and he tried to unbutton her pants (I'm not Casanova, but I think maybe you first try for a kiss or to hold hands). She bent over to stop it and he did. She figured he got the message.

She next met him at a casino, where they had dinner and he walked her to her room. He invited her to his room for dessert. She sat on the bed's edge while they talked (they usually talked about her desire to be a sports commentator or Temple sport) and he then lay down next to her and fell asleep. She believed this was another sexual overture (although, again, I don't get it) but still thought of him as a mentor and was not intimidated.

She left her job and became a masseuse and went to his house to speak about it. She noticed that there was a glass of wine and one of water on the table. At first she didn't want to drink (empty stomach) but finally did when he insisted. Let me quote from the case for the next part:

"At one point, Constand rose to use the restroom. When she returned, Cosby was standing next to the kitchen table with three blue pills in his hand. He reached out and offered the pills to Constand, telling her that the pills were her “friends,” and that they would “help take the edge off.” Constand took the pills from Cosby and swallowed them. The two then sat back down and resumed their discussion of Constand’s planned departure from Temple."

Now, stop one second. Why, in the world, would you (the person who is reading this) put pills in your mouth when you didn't know what they were? Why would you put them in your mouth unless you were used to taking unprescribed drugs. Even as an irresponsible young man, even a beautiful woman offering them would not have made me take them unless I was sick and they were over-the-counter. 

Of course, wine and antihistamines - apparently what they were - are very potent and make even strong drinkers react with dizziness, sleepiness, slur their speech, loss of consciousness and all the qualities of a really drunk person. I've never experienced it (antihistamines alone does that to me), but I've seen other people get completely zonked. I think most intelligent people know its dangerous. Eventually she realized he was fondling her breasts and penetrating her with fingers. Sorry to be graphic, but that is the assault. But, when she awakened, she found her bra out of place and pants unzipped. He was standing in the doorway after she prepared to leave. He told her he had tea and a muffin for her. She had a little and left. Of course, that part is mostly her version.

They continued to talk and be friends. She went out to dinner with him once and then back to his place. He was evasive as to her questions about the pills and what he did. I have to admit, I was curious here and the court really gives no explanation? Why did she keep being friends? Why did she go to dinner with him and then back to his house? She left. We can't tell from the decision if it was in a huff. 

She moved back to Canada a few months later. In January 2005 Cosby came to Toronto and invited her and her mother to a show. That same month she bolted awake, crying and called her mother to confide in her and give her advice. They contacted Canadian police and sought legal counsel in the U.S. She filed a police report, also in Canada. She and her mother placed a call to Cosby to confront him. He said he would tell her after he checked what the blue pills where and "vaguely apologized." He denied to her mother having sexual intercourse with her daughter.

Later, Constand called back and recorded the call. Cosby offered to continue assisting her in a career in sports broadcasting. He also said he would pay for her to continue her education. He wanted to meet personally and said he would have someone set it up. He again refused to say what the pills were.

Constand then got two calls from Cosby reps. The first was an assistant to set up dinner for the three (her mom too). The second was from Cosby's lawyer who said Cosby wanted to set up a trust for her. She declined the first offer and didn't answer the second call. The Canadian police referred the matter to the Philly police.

Montgomery County Dist. Attorney Bruce Castor issued a press release saying Cosby was being investigated for sexual assault (I thought these things were private). Cosby answered written questions while represented by two well known attorneys. Here's his version (the court's summary of that night):

"Constand ingested the pills, they kissed and touched each other on the couch. Cosby admitted that he touched Constands breasts and vagina, but he insisted that she neither resisted nor told him to stop. Additionally, Cosby told the investigators that he never removed his clothing and that Constand did not touch any part of his body under his clothes. Cosby denied having sexual intercourse with Constand and disclaimed any intent to do so that night. In fact, Cosby claimed that the two never had. Cosby admitted that he told Constand and her mother that he would write down the name of the pills and provide them that information, but he acknowledged that he never actually did so. After the interview and without being asked to do so Cosby provided the police with pills, which laboratory testing confirmed to be Benadryl."

Castor was troubled by her not filing a report quickly because it "diminished the reliability of any recollections" and made forensic evidence impossible. He found it atypical behavior between a complainant and a predator. They searched his residence but could not find confirming evidence. He concluded "there was insufficient credible and [so admissible evidence . . . [such that no] could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt."

Castor however, was hardly on Cosby's side. Personally, I thought this was wrong, since he had doubts himself, but also because he was a public officer and his job should not be to try to help one person against another outside of prosecuting crimes. But he decided to intervene, thinking a private suit would be her best bet. He decided to announce that Cosby would not be prosecuted so that in a civil suit he would not be able to rely on the fifth amendment right to silence (only avail so that people's testimony does not make them criminally liable). 

While recognizing that many or most of you already know the following, in case that seems like the legal mumbo jumbo I am trying to avoid  - we have a Constitution put into place in the founding era of our country, that is above all other law in our country. It was soon amended to include a list of rights individuals had. This included the right not to incriminate oneself. It was much later extended to not just federal prosecutions, but to state prosecutions (such as in the Cosby case). It means that someone doesn't have to testify if they feel it might be used to incriminate themselves. We all have this right even if we are or feel innocent. But, there are times when it cannot be used.

Former D.A. Castor later testified, in part:

"So the way you remove that [the fifth amendment protection] is --if you want to, and what did in this case--is I made the decision as the sovereign that Mr. Cosby would not be prosecuted no matter what. As a matter of law, that the made it so that he could not take the Fifth Amendment ever as a matter of law."

It was not an agreement (although Cosby's attorney agreed that it meant if subpoenaed to testify in a civil case, he couldn't raise the defense). 

Castor issued a press release that stated (very brief summary), that both Constand and Cosby cooperated, that the investigation included interviewing other people who claimed Cosby had behaved similarly with them - but none which were ever made into a criminal complaint, that he did not believe a case could be made out beyond reasonable doubt, but as a civil case was still possible, he was not giving an opinion as to credibility of anyone (I don't think he should anyway) but would reconsider "this decision" if he felt he needed to later on.

That last bit about reconsidering "this decision" became very important later on, as you will see. Less than a month after the press release Constand filed a civil case in civil court. Cosby's civil case attorney had learned about the non-prosecution from the criminal case attorney. He understood also that because there was not going to be a prosecution, Cosby could not raise the fifth amendment right not to testify. So, not once during the civil case and the four depositions Cosby sat through, did he or his attorney raise the defense. 

Cosby's version as seen through the depositions differs from Constand and is told in a way that but for the other women who testified, I doubt he would have been convicted (possibly not prosecuted either). Cosby admitted to romantic interests in her, but did not tell her so. He always initiated the personal meeting and home visits. They had sexual activity three times, including the last. The pills were Benadryl, which he was familiar with as he used them to put himself to sleep. When she came to his house in January she was "stressed, tense, and having difficulty sleeping" so Cosby gave her three half pills to relax while they were in the kitchen. She didn't ask what they were and he didn't tell her. He suggested they go into the living room, where she sat next to him and they began kissing and fondling. They lay on the couch where he touched her in the way she later complained of, and after telling her to get to sleep, he went up to his own bedroom. Two hours later he came down and found her awake. He brought her back to the kitchen where they had tea and a muffin.

He also admitted not wanting to tell Constand's mother what the pills were because "he did not want Constand's mother to think that he was a perverted old man who had drugged his daughter and because he had a feeling they were recording the calls. 

Cosby also admitted that he had provided Quaaludes (if unfamiliar to you, it was a nervous system depressant widely used when I was growing up in the '60s-'80s - and, no, not me) to other women with whom he wanted to have sex in the past. The case settled for 3.38 million but the settlement and depositions were sealed until 2015 following a media request.

Castor was no longer D.A.* His first assistant, Risa Vetri Ferman, was now the D.A. She resumed the investigation.  When Castopr learned what Ferman had done so, he sent her an email to which he had

Castor was D.A. in Montgomery County, Pa. from 2000-2008. He had many other similar positions including as Solicitor General and Attorney General of Pennsylvania. He's a highly regarded attorney. He also represented Trump in the second impeachment trial. I'll also note in passing that Constand also sued Castor for defamation and that there was a confidential settlement thereafter. No idea if there was a payment included or what it was.

attached the 2005 press release. He restated his position that Cosby couldn't be prosecuted. He also said he believed that if Cosby was prosecuted that he would have a lawsuit against the County and her personally. She replied by letter that it was the first she had learned about a binding understanding between the Commonwealth and Cosby. Oddly, in his reply, he ended with "Naturally, if a prosecution could be made without using what Cosby said (in his civil case depositions), or anything derived from what Cosby said, I believed then and continue to believe that a prosecution is not precluded. However, you will see below, he explains why he said it.

Ferman's team pressed forward anyway, including with Constand's cooperation, "even though she had specifically agreed not to do so as part of the civil settlement." 

About a decade after Castor's decision not to prosecute, one was filed charging Cosby with three counts of aggravated indecent assault. Cosby made a motion (called habeus corpus) to set aside the prosecution because of Castor's promise not to prosecute. The trial court denied that motion stating that the record indicated no agreement had been made between the Commonwealth (that is, Pennsylvania) and Cosby, but only prosecutorial discretion not to prosecute (note, prosecutors have tremendous latitude in deciding what to prosecute or not). 

In making its decision, the trial court included Castor's testimony that he intended his decision to be absolute. But, then it pointed out that his press release stated, "District Attorney Castor cautions all parties to this matter that he will reconsider this decision should the need arise." However, by including this statement in the paragraph about the Civil Case, he was advising "the parties that if they criticized his decision, he would contact the media and explain that Ms. Constand's actions damaged her credibility, which would severely hamper her civil case." However, she noted that in an article to the Philadephia Inquirer, he said that he put it in there to indicate that if "any evidence surfaced that was admissible I would revisit the issue."

Though Castor, said the trial judge, was sending a message to the media, to the litigants and to the legal community in general (again, how this is his job as a prosecutor, I couldn't tell you). 

The trial court also noted that Mr. Castor testified that he intended to "confer transactional immunity" upon Cosby, meaning he couldn't be prosecuted for the acts of that day at all, and was doing so by virtue of his as sovereign derived from the common law. There was no "agreement." It was also pointed out that Constand's attorney's also testified that they only learned of the press statement from a reporter, that they had asked for nothing and believed that Cosby's own statements to the D.A. prevented him from raising the Fifth Amendment defense, and, even if he succeeded, the jury could be told that (since it was not a criminal case), they could infer his guilt from that and they would only have Constand's version anyway. She did not take Castor's statement that he might revisit to mean anything other than he might prosecute later on, and not a threat not to criticize him. In the settlement, Constand agreed not to initiate a a criminal complaint (you have to wonder, why did Cosby's attorney's want this if they thought there was an absolute promise not to prosecute?)

It gets murkier though. When asked why he ended his correspondence with the new D.A. (his former assistant) he said that Cosby could be prosecuted without the depositions, he stated that he meant "only if other victims were discovered, with charges related only to those victims, and without the use of Cosby's depositions in the Constand matter."

In the end, the trial court decided that Castor did not have authority to convey transactional immunity on a person as the sovereign, that he should have followed the statutory plan for immunity (applying to a court), and that his testimony was equivocal as to the immunity he intended.

There were actually two Cosby criminal trials. In the first one, they picked jurors from another county, though held the trial in Montgomery County. The court allowed only one other woman who claimed Cosby treated her in like fashion to testify, and the jury found it could not reach a decision (thus, a mistrial). 

At the second trial, the prosecutors sought to include the testimony of 19 women who would claim similar acts by Cosby, ranging from fifteen to twenty-two years prior to the charged crime. The trial court increased the number of other women who could testify to five of the nineteen. The Supreme Court* noted here that there had been no change of circumstances for this decision to increase the witnesses. Although in the end, they did not decide whether this was right or wrong, I think it hinted that it had a problem with the decision. I will say, if you want to find the court's decision, a summary of the five's testimony is given and after reading it, you will have no sympathy for Cosby, unless you decide all of them (and all the others) were being untruthful. As I said earlier, I think he's a rapist. Although evidence of "prior bad acts" is always problematic in criminal law, I think the trial judge did a good job of considering the factors, and agree that remoteness in time is only one factor. 

*Unless I state I mean the Supreme Court of the United States, what I mean herein when I say "Supreme Court," is the highest court in Pennsylvania, which also uses that name.

Cosby was convicted after the second trial. He received 3-15 years as a sentence. That means, with good behavior, he could be paroled after the second year. He has been non-repentant, saying that even if it hurt his chances for parole, he would state what he thought. In fact, only about a month before the Pa. Supreme Court decision, he was denied parole for refusing to participate in the sexual offender's program while imprisoned.

Needless to say, he appealed. Though there was an intermediate court (Superior Court) decision in which the prosecution prevailed, I'm just leaving it out because, frankly, nobody wants to read that much, even though that it was what was actually appealed. Suffice to say it agreed with the lower court. Onto the Supreme Court reasoning.

Cosby appealed two issues. The first was whether the "allegations of uncharged misconduct involving sexual contact with five women (and a de fact sixth) and the use of Quaaludes should have been admitted given they dated as far back as the 1970s, and so forth. The second was whether Cosby could rely on D.A. Castor's decision not to prosecute and therefore should not have been prosecuted (nor the civil depositions used if he could be).

Actually, the court did not decide the first issue at all because in deciding he should not have been prosecuted, the evidentiary issues didn't matter anymore. It's just about Castor's decision.

Remember, the lower court that tried Cosby decided that what Castor did was a "failed attempt to reach a statutorily prescribed transactional immunity agreement. Second, the court concluded that the former district attorney's testimony regarding the legal relationship between him and Cosby was inconsistent and 'equivocal at best." 

The Supreme Court, looking at the record, decided that the record actually did not contradict D.A. Castor's testimony and that the D.A. and Cosby('s attorneys) never contemplated an immunity agreement and it was really just an exercise of the D.A. conferring transactional immunity (the whole shebang - Cosby could no longer be prosecuted) based on Common Law (that is, judicial law or decisions established over time and not an act of the legislature). What that means is according to the law of Pennsylvania, not written by the legislature, but as decided by judges, the D.A. as the representative of the sovereign state, has authority to decide not to prosecute someone. 

Unfortunately, then the Supreme Court says that there is some support in the record that his testimony was inconsistent and equivocal (it could mean either), which makes it a little confusing. The Supreme Court decided it was bound by the lower court's decision of the fact that there was no agreement between the D.A. and Cosby and also that there was no formal immunity agreement. However, they are not bound by the lower court to determine what legal effect it all has. It is a question of law as to whether Castor's decision binds future D.A's.

Prosecutors wear several hats, though it does not always seem so the way they behave. They are officers of the court, advocates for victims and administrators of justice. In other words, they just can't always try to convict but have to "seek justice within the bounds of the law." Frankly, in real life, prosecutors see these two things as the same. Convicting equals justice. That's why we have courts.

The court also noted the tremendous power of prosecutors, how more than any other person they have the power over people's freedom and tremendous discretion. Even the Supreme Court of the U.S. rarely ever interferes with a charging decision.

Because of this tremendous power, it "has long been recognized the special weight that must be accorded to their assurances." So, for instance, if in a plea deal, if the prosecutor makes a promise, the promise must be fulfilled (which is why they are often careful not to promise unless the court agrees). That the promises are fulfilled are part of our constitutional right to "due process." 

The Supreme Court believed that the press release was unequivocal. The trial court thought that Castor's statement cautioning "all parties to this matter that (Castor) will reconsider this decision should the need arise" meant it was not unequivocal (remember I said earlier this would be important), but that was forgetting that this sentence came in the paragraph about a civil action and not discussing the matter in public. 

Because he made these statements and because Cosby and his counsel relied on them in not refusing to testify because it might incriminate him), it became a matter of due process. The importance of the right not to incriminate oneself and due process is so great, that sometimes we even let criminals go free. And, that's what happened here. "Cosby did not invoke the Fifth Amendment before he incriminated himself because he was operating under the reasonable belief that D.A. Castor’s decision not to prosecute him meant that “the potential exposure to criminal punishment no longer exist[ed].”

Moreover, it was entirely reasonable for Cosby to rely on his attorneys advice and therefore weakening his right to counsel. "To hold otherwise would recast our understanding of reasonableness into something unrecognizable and unsustainable under our law." Defendants would have to disbelieve their own attorneys and the word of the D.A.   

Now, what to do about it. Two judges dissented and it was argued that if the court overturned the decision it should let them try Cosby a third time. But, it's too late for that. The only reasonable remedy for Cosby giving up his right not to incriminate himself with testimony and for relying on what Castor promised, is to do what Castor intended, bar any future prosecution of Cosby in Pa.

At the end of the day, the court ruled that "when a prosecutor makes an unconditional promise of non-prosecution, and when the defendant relies upon that guarantee to the detriment of his constitutional right not to testify, the principle of fundamental fairness that undergirds due process of law in our criminal justice system demands that the promise be enforced."

That's it. Sorry if it was long, but I didn't want to leave out anything fundamental to the decision. I personally don't think that I would have found Cosby guilty in this one case, because of the year of a continued personal relationship. I understand how this could happen to someone who is abused, but it is sad because it does almost always raise reasonable doubt in fair minds. For the sake of argument, presuming that Constand was abused and feels that justice was not served, I feel horrible for her, as I do believe all those other women (at least many of them) are not lying.  She may be right. Probably she feels betrayed by the justice system. Maybe I would too. And, obviously, some justices agree with her.  But, in fairness, these cases must be decided by those who do not have a stake in them.

Thursday, June 24, 2021

Maybe Brandi is a nice person, but right now, I don't like her much.

Let me take a break from my usual assault on fascism in our country and talk about a Supreme Court case that just came down. I haven't talked about a particular case in a while. This one is MAHANOY AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT v. B. L. It's a case about free speech in high school. BL was a minor when the action was brought and her real name is Brandi Levi. As usual when discussing cases, I'm not going all legally-schmegally, citing cases and the like. If you want to read the case - 20-255 Mahanoy Area School Dist. v. B. L. (06/23/2021) (supremecourt.gov).

So, essentially, here are the important facts. Brandi was a student at a Pennsylvania High School who at the end of her freshman year tried out for varsity cheerleading and right fielder on a private (not school) team. She was only offered a spot on the J.V. cheerleading team and she did not get the softball position she wanted. Let's agree, she wasn't a good sport about it. She went with a friend to a store and put on her own phone two snapchats (I heard of snapchat, but of course have no idea what it is - but now I know it's social media that lets you put up pictures and videos that fade away after some time). Anyone on her friend's group could see them for 24 hours. One photo showed her and her friend raising their middle fingers (you know what that means, right?) and the caption read "Fuck school fuck softball fuck cheer fuck everything." I'm violating my own no cursing policy because the Supreme Court used those words. The other photo had no picture but basically a complaint that someone got on the varsity team who wasn't a freshman and she had been was told that's why she couldn't be on it. Wah wah wah. Oh, and an upside down smiley face, which I personally feel are creepy, but no one else in the world agrees with me and it's not the issue here. The photograph is.

So, even adults never seem to learn - if you put things online, other people can see them. Some of her "friends" were on the team. One of her group took pictures of it and showed her mom, a coach on the team. See where this is going? Some of the cheerleaders were upset and spoke to coaches about it. Two of the coaches taught an algebra class and apparently there was a discussion about it. 

Brandi apologized for what she had done, after being suspended from cheerleading for a year, but it did not help. She and her parents sued, claiming her first amendment rights were violated (that is, she could say what she wanted).  

Let me say, I don't think what Brandi did was horrible. She was about 14, I'm guessing, and though it is impolite to say that, 14 year olds are often pretty stupid (also, it turns out, people of every age group - BECAUSE THEY NEVER SEEM TO LEARN NOT TO POST! - I'm sure including me). Even if a grown up did it, it isn't horrible. But, a grown up might get fired over it (and a lot less). 

The trial court (in federal court, called District Court) undid the suspension, gave Brandi a little bit of money ("nominal damages") and attorney's fees, which could be a lot of money. I don't know how much they got. 

So, basically, we all have some first amendment speech rights. It's not absolute. We all should know that. You know, you can't scream "fire" in a crowded theatre, can't use fighting words to someone's face, that kind of thing. And, some people have more rights than others depending on the circumstances. You can't always say what you want at work or . . . in school. This is not the first case like this, but, usually, the school wins. Here, the middle court (Court of Appeals) agreed with the trial court and the Supreme Court agreed to. Here's why.

Public schools can regulate some speech on school premises because they have this mission to educate the children and also a duty to protect them from injury or the like while they have them. They can regulate speech on-campus if it "materially disrupts class work or involves substantial disorder or invasion of the rights of others." Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School Dist. (1969). The school stands "in loco parentis" - that is, in the place of the parents. 

You might think, that's fine while they are in school, but not when they are out of school. Actually, they can regulate some "off-campus" speech by students, according to Tinker. 

Usually, it's dangerous or disruptive things like "serious or severe bullying or harassment targeting particular individuals; threats aimed at teachers or other students; the failure to follow rules concerning les[1sons, the writing of papers, the use of computers, or participation in other online school activities; and breaches of school security devices."  So, if I threaten you (imagine we are kids) out of school, the school might suspend me because it might result in violence. Or, if I write your paper outside of school, maybe I'll get in trouble for that. 

But, in general, the courts are more skeptical of the regulations when it's off-campus speech. For one thing, because we pretend that schools are the "nurseries of  democracy" we want to protect their even unpopular speech.

The Supreme court decided because the photo was sent outside of school hours, off of school grounds, did not identify or target any particular person with vulgar/abusive language, sent the photo through her own smart phone to her "friends," and it really didn't disrupt school for more than a few minutes (the algebra class) and, the court believes it wouldn't disrupt unity on the team (really? - does anyone on the court know any teenage girls?), it wasn't sufficient to trigger the school's right to punish her.  

That's it in a nutshell, and though I was much shorter than the court, I didn't leave much out.

Usually, I am very pro-first amendment, believe we should have it as much as possible, but I disagreed here with 8 of the judges. The only one who dissented (voted against) was Judge Thomas. More and more I find in a case I agree with either him or Alito, but not always. Justice Thomas and I also agree with the Biden Administration, which is only ironic in that both us probably disagree a lot with it. 

Just to give you the skinny on Thomas' opinion - he felt the court ignored the history and cases which gave schools more authority than they suggested off campus when the speech affected the school environment (I'm paraphrasing). He reminds them of a Vermont case, as an example, where a kid at home said in front of a teacher and some other students that the teacher was "old" (apparently said disrespectfully. The principle of the case was that if that the speech had “a direct and immediate tendency to injure the school, to sub[1vert the master’s authority, and to beget disorder and insubordination” and therefore found the kid could be disciplined. It would not have been allowed if the speech was “in no ways connected with or affecting the school” or had “merely a remote and indirect tendency to injure.” 

Although I think the case he cited had too little of an insult ("old") for me to conclude it would have usurped the teacher's authority, it was at least borderline. Last of all, Thomas points out that what off-campus means now isn't what it used to mean. 

So, this is what I think. The first amendment free speech rights are super important. I don't want the content of anyone's speech to go unsaid even if I hate it. I want Brandi to always be able to say her opinion. But, I do think the school should be able to discipline kids' speech in some areas because they do have to be able to run a school, and frankly, we have dropped the ball so much in education that we can't afford to let discipline in school get worse than it is. 

Let's be honest. Yes, her opinion obviously is that the school, cheerleaders, etc., sucks. Okay. But, using the phrase "Fuck school fuck softball fuck cheer fuck everything" is more than just an opinion just like saying, I think you should die, is more than an opinion. It's a well known expression of disgust, hate or contempt. And people take it very personally. Don't tell me that racial slurs can be out of bounds if "fuck" isn't, because we all know it pisses people off something fierce. Unless someone knows they are joking (like if we say it to an acquaintance where the context is obvious), saying "Fuck X," is always personal, negative and meant to gather attention. Just because she has an opinion doesn't mean she gets any special privilege than someone who just said it without an opinion attached.  

Why shouldn't the cheerleading coaches (who did discuss it with the administration first) get to say, we don't want her on the team this year, and reasonably so. If you found out some Brandi-like kid said "Fuck you," about you and say, your swimming pool, would you want your kid to invite her over to go swimming? Of course, school is different than our private lives, but the teachers and coaches are people, and so are the kids on the team who were upset. And was it really that big of a punishment. No. It was mild. She wasn't suspended from school. She didn't even get attention. It pretty much was, okay, you hate us, don't be with us - and for just the one year. Limited in time, limited in scope. As I said, Brandi didn't do anything horrible to begin with. But, obviously, it would tend to upset people and make being on a team difficult.  Her opinion is her own (I had no problem with the other post) to have. Even if she is in school, she should not be deprived of stating an opinion (short of ones in school that might put people in fear - like screaming "fire" in a crowded lunchroom). 

Now, about that off-campus thing. What does it matter anymore. Who has more power, by a factor of a million perhaps. Me, going on campus and whispering something in someone's ear, or, someone sitting at home on facebook with a thousand (or 50,000 or a million) "friends." Even the court seems to recognize that the impact of the behavior has to count even when off-campus. Social media is so powerful because it has become the actual village commons. A student who makes mischief in class is comparing a pea-shooter to a howitzer. Social media can reach so many people, and the idea that it was just her friends doesn't make any difference when some of them were cheerleaders themselves, or the daughter of a coach, or even because any of them can print it out or take a picture of it. 

It's not like I'm saying something new either. We've had things long-arm jurisdiction for example for the longest time so that a person can sue in a state where they are injured when it was caused by someone who did something in another state and it was foreseeable that whatever it was would cause the problem elsewhere. Just as an example, if I sell a product, say a car, in Florida that is defective and it blows up in New York, I can be sued in NY. Technology often lets us stretch our natural capacities. When they wrote the constitution there were no telephones. Now, I can make a threat in California on the line with you in Maine. Or if I put in online, everyone can know. Something like "Fuck school . . ." is exactly the type of thing that is likely to go flying around school every bit as much as when Esther challenges Jane to a fight in the playground after school with two friends present. Soon everyone knows. Nowadays, the challenge would probably be made on social media. Think about it. If it counts against someone when they make a threat online and are not on school grounds - they feel an online off-campus threat has an effect on people on-campus (even if not there at the moment). Why would it be any different if it's a curse out. It can reach them the same way.

I probably would have a different opinion if she was suspended from school for cursing it out. But, school is a necessity, required by law, and important for her too. And I would take into consideration that she wasn't shouting it at the people in person. But, this is cheerleading, and that is not required, it is not the law, and it is a privilege to be on a team. Very different, and no one took that into consideration, or that her presence would effect the coaches and other cheerleaders. We have a problem in this country in making the bullies the good guys and the victims the bad guys. This is one example. That doesn't mean she shouldn't have free speech, but this has nothing to do with that. It has to do with cursing out your coach and team.

So, maybe Brandi is an awesome kid and this is the one thing she did wrong in her life (and once more, it wasn't that terrible). That's something the school and her teachers might take into consideration. But, I think her parents did the wrong thing here. They should have said, Brandi, time you learned the danger of social media, and time you learned your actions have consequences. Don't go putting "Fuck" anyone on social media if you don't want them to read it. I wish everyone would learn that lesson. Again, this was a mild punishment. People lose their jobs and don't get to cry to a court over much smaller things, including just having an opinion. 

The shame is, because it's a civil rights case, the school has to pay Brandi's parents legal fees. That just isn't right either, in my book, because if anything, at the very least - this was a close call and she was obnoxious. The school wasn't out to stifle her rights. There was no racism or anti-Brandi feeling. She cursed the school  and team out because she is a sore loser and they did what any responsible parent or school standing in the parents' shoes would do - they mildly punished her so she'd learn a lesson. The court did not have to grant attorney's fees. Schools are already terrified of litigation, avoid normal activities to avoid it. This might have a terrible impact on schools (that are already cowardly and fear litigation), make them even more afraid to discipline children even if it's on-campus or more brazenly online. Organizations and their lawyers bend over backwards to avoid trouble. The court should not grant those fees. 

Last point. The snapchat happened in 2017. She was 14, I guess now 18. 4 years is not a long time by Supreme Court standards (a case they decided a few days ago started 16 years ago). I wonder how Brandi's life at school turned out and if she ever went back on the team. Just curious. Maybe it's on social media, but I'm not. 

About Me

My photo
I started this blog in September, 2006. Mostly, it is where I can talk about things that interest me, which I otherwise don't get to do all that much, about some remarkable people who should not be forgotten, philosophy and theories (like Don Foster's on who wrote A Visit From St. Nicholas and my own on whether Santa is mostly derived from a Norse god) and analysis of issues that concern me. Often it is about books. I try to quote accurately and to say when I am paraphrasing (more and more). Sometimes I blow the first name of even very famous people, often entertainers. I'm much better at history, but once in a while I see I have written something I later learned was not true. Sometimes I fix them, sometimes not. My worst mistake was writing that Beethoven went blind, when he actually went deaf. Feel free to point out an error. I either leave in the mistake, or, if I clean it up, the comment pointing it out. From time to time I do clean up grammar in old posts as, over time I have become more conventional in my grammar, and I very often write these when I am falling asleep and just make dumb mistakes. It be nice to have an editor, but . . . .